Wednesday, March 09, 2011

“Rape is the only crime in which the victim becomes the accused.” - Freda Adler

If I was a journalist, and I was reporting on the alleged gang rape of an 11 year old girl, I imagine I would discuss the horror of the situation. I would talk to experts on child rape, and perhaps provide sources of support and information. I would write about the long-term effects that such an assault can have on a girl, and I would perhaps discuss what may be involved in the legal process ahead for this child and the accused men and boys.

However, in researching the story, I found this,
But this is a case that has divided this Liberty County town.

Some sympathize with the suspects, saying the alleged victim was a willing participant, even though she is too young to give legal consent
as reported in My Fox Houston and elsewhere.

That information would change my approach altogether. Her local community and fellow students coming out with statements like,
""To be honest, she looks older than she really is," says Brandi Foster",


"“Where was her mother? What was her mother thinking?” said Ms. Harrison, one of a handful of neighbors who would speak on the record"

This girl was allegedly raped by as many as 20 men and boys. She was 11 years old.

Not only are the child, and her mother, being blamed for her assault, an awful lot of concern is expressed for the defendants.
“It’s just destroyed our community,” said Sheila Harrison, 48, a hospital worker who says she knows several of the defendants. “These boys have to live with this the rest of their lives.”


“It’s devastating, and it’s really tearing our community apart,” she said. “I really wish that this could end in a better light.” (from NY Times)


Sherry Fletcher, whose 20-year-old son Devo Shaun Green is among those charged, spoke to the network about her son's arrest. She said: 'It just seems like a dream. 'I just hope everything comes out well, because some of these kids are innocent.' (from Daily Mail, safe link).

Why is nobody asking what happened in one community to potentially create 20 rapists? Why is nobody expressing concern for the child at all? Why is it that the concern about the legal action is focused on the effect on the accused men, not the effect on the girl?

And if I was a journalist reporting this story, I would never, ever do what the New York Times in particular did, and report uncritically on a community's victim-blaming of an 11 year old girl who has had video of her alleged gang rape passed around her school, and which is now being investigated by the police.

James McKinley, the journalist, considers it newsworthy that
Residents in the neighborhood where the abandoned trailer stands — known as the Quarters — said the victim had been visiting various friends there for months. They said she dressed older than her age, wearing makeup and fashions more appropriate to a woman in her 20s. She would hang out with teenage boys at a playground, some said.

He does not report that it does not matter what a woman or girl is wearing. It does not matter if she 'dresses her age' or not. It does not matter if she wears make-up. He does not even question these statements, he just quotes them as they stand. He does not even mention that an 11 year old child is considered to be always incapable of consent in the law.

People should know better. The New York Times in particular should.

Other online reports of this story have comments like,
It doesn't make it right but when all the truth comes out I won't be surprised if it turns out that she was telling everyone she was 17 yrs old and that she probably orchestrated the whole thing. A lot of young people's lives will be ruined by this young, promiscuous girl. Something this big had to have been planned. Put them all in jail including the young girl.

This misogyny has to end! It does not even matter if she had told anyone she was 17. Or 27. Or 87. Women and girls get raped through no fault of their own. How many times do we need to report this until it is understood?

Thank you to Women's eNews for the photo, and to Liz Henry for the heads-up to the story.

(cross-posted at The F Word blog).


Anonymous said...

Jesus. This is just sickening. I hope the girl and her family realize that there are a lot of us out there who would not put up with this at all. They probably feel like they are alone in this world, devolution is seemingly real.

butterflywings said...

Well said. *Tries to write something coherent* It makes me so angry that society is still at this level when discussing rape.

She was 11. And you know what? Unless the victim is a nun (and ha, probably even then they'd find something) if she's female, she's done something wrong to deserve it. So she may have looked and behaved older than 11, so what? If she had in fact been 21 and had slept with every male in sight including multiple men at the same time, so what? If she didn't consent at that time to what happened, it was rape. It is that easy. Why don't men get it? *Wants to hit people with clue stick until they get it*.

Anonymous said...

If I were a commenter on a story about an accusation of rape I would not write "It makes me so angry that society is still at this level when discussing rape."

If I were a journalist I'd listen to the local community because they tend to know what's going down and how people are.

I hope that when the Incurable Hippie takes to the witness's just occurred to me that she might be a misandrist rather than a witness.

Anonymous said...

I thought the same thing when I read some of the stories about this case. People said she looked older and dressed provocatively. I don't care if she was 30 and walking around in a bikini she didn't deserve to be gang-raped!

It drives me nuts how people defend their family members when they do something like this. If my son did this my heart would break but I can't imagine defending him for it.

Laban said...

I get the impression local people are dividing on community lines. The girl is Hispanic, her alleged assailants are not.

Maria said...

It is natural for young girls to dress up. At that age girls want to be heard and feel as if they matter. It is rediculous for people to even think that it was her fault.She is only elleven years old! It would be amazing if that little girl even had her period.At that age she was not looking for sexual attention,jeez you dont even really start having an increase in your estrogen levels until your 14. That poor baby,those men deserve the death penalty

Froggypop said...

she might be a misandrist

Misandry isn't a real thing. Men are not systematically oppressed, they are the driving force behind rape culture.